Twitter: woodstockinst Facebook: 305087839971 YouTube: woodstockinst Google Plus 2: woodstockinstitute Flickr: 48923005@N07 FeedBurner: woodstockinst
The Challenges Facing Communities of Color
Written by Geoff Smith   
Friday, 06 May 2011 21:03

I'm guest-blogging at Credit Slips this week about our new bankruptcy report, consumer debt, and more. Below is an excerpt from one of these posts.

Yesterday, I posted a chart highlighting changes in refinance lending in Chicago between 2008 and 2009.  It showed lending doubling in predominantly white communities but dropping by over 40 percent in communities of color. To me, this chart illustrates my concerns about the directions in which these respective communities might be heading in the wake of the foreclosure and economic crisis. Whatever the reasons are behind the drop in conventional lending to communities of color, it ultimately means that they will face significant challenges to recovery.

As some noted yesterday in the comments to my post, these trends should not be surprising.  Communities of color in Chicago and across the country have been devastated by the foreclosure and economic crisis.  They have seen disproportionately high concentrations of foreclosure activity which affects neighborhood property values and likely puts a substantial portion of non-delinquent homeowners  underwater.  Areas with high concentrations of foreclosure activity are also going to see higher levels of distressed sales (properties that are sold either during the foreclosure process as a short sale or after the completion of a foreclosure as a lender-owned property).  The prices of distressed sales are often below market value and can affect appraisals.  In areas where the only sales are distressed, it is difficult for lenders to assess the true value of a non-distressed property for a refinance loan, making lending in these communities more challenging.  In addition, we know that communities of color have disproportionately high levels of unemployment; that large quantities of wealth have been extracted from these communities through payday lending, predatory mortgages, and other costs associated with the fringe financial system; that a higher percentage of people in communities of color have low or no credit scores; and that many people in these communities have overwhelming levels of debt.

A lot of Woodstock’s work revolves around documenting these challenges because, without evidence and data showing their scale, distribution, and concentration, it’s difficult for stakeholders to act effectively and intelligently.  There is no shortage of challenges to document, but what are the solutions?

Read the rest of the story

 

add comment Comments (1)

Colin said:

...
Geoff,

I'm curious to know if your report considered the possibility that Chapter 13 may be the most advantageous option for African-American's, if it is true that they were more frequently targeted by mortgage companies selling home equity loans. In a Chapter 13, and only in a Chapter 13, a debtor is able to strip the second mortgage if their house is worth less than their first mortgage This can often relieve a debtor of a greater debt burden, and provide them and their family with the security of knowing that they will keep their house, and have 3 to 5 years of the mortgage paid of by the time the Chapter 13 Plan is completed. If the issue that I raise is correct, the disproportionate number of Chapter 13's is not caused by the bankruptcy system, but the effect of unscrupulous creditors.

I look forward to your response.

Thank you,

Colin
May 11, 2011

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 
Discussion topics

access to banking services affordable housing asset limit reform bankruptcy building savings CDFIs CFPA consumer loan reform CRA credit cards credit scores credit unions data stories debt settlement EITC federal reg reform foreclosures from the president global Guest post HAMP analyses HMDA Illinois Community Investment Coalition loan modifications mortgage lending online community lending fact book overdraft loans photo policy press release RALs reading list Regional HOPI retirement security small business vacant properties video wealth building wh

Latest Comments
Homeowners receiving Illinois Hardest Hi...
I received a Loan Modification from my lender, probably due to filing with Illinois Hardest Hit. I am attempting to see how well others have faired. ...
Data underscore need for principal reduc...
1. Servicers, not investors, make the decisions to modify, foreclose, or not, with little regulation, oversite, or accountability. 2. Servicers get ...
Receive email updates






A member of:
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
29 E. Madison, Suite 1710 | Chicago, Illinois 60602-4566 | (312) 368-0310 tel | (312) 368-0316 fax
| Careers | Privacy | Site Map | Distribution/Linking Policy | Calendar of Events | Donate | Browse all documents |